calendar_header.jpg

Athens County Fair Photos
CLICK ON IMAGES TO VIEW GALLERY

community_header.jpg
visitors_guide.jpg
annual_manual.jpg
lodging_guide.jpg
best_of_athens.jpg
bridal_guide_1.jpg
announcements.jpg

soa_300x100.jpg


 

 

 

 

 

 

 
Home / Articles / Editorial / Wearing Thin /  OK, maybe these particular tea parties/libery bells are different
. . . . . . .
Thursday, February 25,2010

OK, maybe these particular tea parties/libery bells are different

By Terry Smith

If I were giving advice to U.S. Rep. Zack Space, I'd tell him to steer clear of any of the potential ambushes that an umbrella group for Ohio tea parties and conservative groups has planned for the months leading up to the May 4 primary.

That is, unless the Ohio Liberty Council disavows the racist and violent rhetoric that has become common at tea party events across the country, and promises that its members will act like civilized adults rather than a lynch mob. (The group insists that it treats its guest speakers civilly and respectfully, but more on that later.)


In a news release issued Monday, the Ohio Liberty Council, describing itself as "a non-partisan grass-roots volunteer organization comprised of leaders from tea party and other liberty-minded groups," said it has invited all the candidates running in the 18th Congressional District primary election in May.

The Liberty Council's coalition includes the Buckeye Firearms Association, "9/12 projects" in Central Ohio and Columbus (groups inspired by Fox News flamethrower Glenn Beck), tea parties in Dayton and Cincinnati, and other "liberty" groups. (Editor's note: In the original version of this column, I described the Buckeye gun group as "a hard conservative political group that disguises itself as a gun-rights outfit." That unfairly suggested that their primary focus is something other than gun rights. That's not the case, and I apologize for the misstatement. TS)

Though perched on the right fringe of American politics, the groups purport to represent a groundswell of citizen taxpayers who are angry about government encroachment into the private sphere. And while the Republican Party has been ardently courting tea party and 9/12 groups, many of them lean to the right of the very right-leaning GOP, and have expressed distrust of both parties.

So what's not to like about people joining together to impact politics in the name of liberty?

Well, the first thing not to like is their co-opting of words such as "liberty-minded" and "patriots," with the implication that anyone who doesn't subscribe to their agenda is neither a patriot nor a lover of freedom.

Some other things to be concerned about when these people start feeling their oats:

"˘ Repeatedly last summer, tea party get-togethers with members of Congress wound up being ambushes where self-indulgently angry citizens shouted down, intimidated and bullied their democratically elected representatives. (Things have to get pretty ugly before I'll feel sorry for your average congressman.)

"˘ Racist, violent and inflammatory signs and placards have been common at tea party events. Some of the messages: "Geld Obama" (which hearkens back to Slave Era threats to castrate "uppity" male slaves); "Obama's Plan: White Slavery"; "The American Taxpayers Are the Jews for Obama's Ovens"; "Barack Hussein Obama: The New Face of Hitler" (with a doctored photo of the president, wearing a Hitler mustache and Nazi uniform); a poster with a cartoon showing President Obama slitting the throat of Uncle Sam; "Barack Obama Supports Abortion, Sodomy, Socialism and The New World Order"; "Obama Was Not Bowing: He Was Sucking Saudi Jewels!" (with a cartoon of Obama, well, trying to suck an Arab's jewels); "Impeach Osama Obama, aka Hussein"; "Obama = Hitler"; "This Is What It Must Have Felt Like in 1776, Can You Feel the Revolution?"; "Obama Socialist Pig"; and "Hang 'Em High: Traitors in Congress "“ Pelosi, Reid, Waters, Schumer, Fran, Dodd, Conyers Kerry, Clinton..." (Thanks to the Huffington Post for compiling many photos showing this stuff.)

"˘ Right-wing radicals in the crowds at McCain-Palin rallies in fall of 2008 hollering, "Kill him!" and "Terrorist!" in reference to Obama.

"˘ The chilling statement at a recent tea party gathering in eastern Washington state in which tea party planner Dianne Capps, of the Lewis & Clark Tea Party Patriots, said she'd like to hang Washington state Rep. Patty Murray. Here's what Capps told a crowd of about 600 tea partiers:

First she asked the crowd if they had seen the classic Western mini-series "Lonesome Dove" (based on Larry McMurtry's Pulitizer Prize-winning novel).

Then she asked, "What happened to Jake (Spoon) when he ran with the wrong crowd?

"He got hung. And that's what I want to do with Patty Murray."

Capps later tried to soften her words by saying that she had added, "hang Patty Murray, by vote," but the TV station that recorded the bit said the recording doesn't show any such thing.

"˘ This is a small thing, though I thought it was interesting. The headline to the news release about the Ohio Liberty Council's invitation to 18th District candidates reads: "Tea Party and Liberty Groups Make Candidates Stand and Deliver at District Candidates Nights." The term "Stand and Deliver" was the common instruction that 17th and 18th century British highwaymen gave to travelers they were robbing at gunpoint.

IT'S IRONIC THAT many in the tea party movement are comparing our president to Adolf Hitler, based on his wanting more government involvement with health care (which would make us more like such Nazi-like regimes as, um, Sweden and Canada).

The irony stems from the fact that these loosely organized tea party groups bare a striking resemblance to the various angry, populist right-wing groups that developed in post-war Germany in the early 1920s in response to the total economic collapse at that time. These bullying "brown shirts" eventually coalesced into the National Socialist Party, and, as they say, the rest is history.

The fact that white supremacist and virulently racist anti-immigration groups are increasingly being drawn into the tea party movement just reinforces the comparison.

This isn't to say that all tea partiers are potentially violent or racist, or even the vast majority of them. Many are sincerely concerned about the economy, government spending and taxation, and can make a reasoned argument against big government.

Indeed, the Ohio Liberty Council insists that it's a peaceful outfit that encompasses several groups in addition to tea parties. The council's "media team" informed me Tuesday that they adhere to a code of ethics that promotes positive discussion, civility and respect toward guests.

They said they provide security at their large events, "and all of our meetings have been civil, and there have been no arrests, citations, or complaints from attendees, speakers or guests."

However, they declined to disavow the inflammatory actions of tea party groups, including the "hanging" threat made at the Washington state rally.

I would suggest to the Ohio Liberty Council that if they want to gain support from more than a small fraction of the voting public, and jettison their wing-nut reputation, they should aggressively distance themselves from the inflammatory, violent and racist approach too often seen at tea party rallies and events.

As for the question of the day - will Congressman Space accept an invitation from a hard conservative group that so obviously despises him? - that's doubtful. A spokesman for his campaign said Wednesday that Space "looks forward to debating the issues that are important to Ohioans with the nominee that the Republican Party chooses in May. While the Republicans continue to have an intra-party squabble and fight amongst themselves, Zack Space is going to (do a lot of wonderful stuff)."

 

  • Currently 3.5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Excellent, informative article on far right. I particularly liked your use of multiple sources and the effective organization of the article

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
Terry once again you have not only entertained me but educated me a little. I consider myself to be a deomcrat, but I do believe in efficent governement, not big governement or small..just something big enough and decent enough to get the job done. I also tend to think that half these "tea party" and Glen Beck cultists wouldn't be around if our President was *gasp* white. They (tea party) really need to re-look history and really read the Bill of Rights and the Constitution and see that it is not end all be all or laws, but a blueprint of how governemnt is supposed to operate.

 

I must beg to differ with your last sentence. The Constitution IS the be all and end all of law in America - it is the supreme law of the land. The Supreme Court has found all throughout America's history that any legislation or rule that is repugnant to the Constitution is 'null and void.' (Marbury v. Madison) "An unconstitutional act is not law; it confers no rights; it imposes no duties; affords no protection; it carries no office; it is in legal contemplation, as inoperative as though it had never been passed." (Norton v. Shelby County) "Where rights secured by the Constitution are involved, there can be no rule making or legislation which would abrogate them." Miranda v.Arizona. Our rights are absolute and unalienable. The Constitution is the be all and end all of all legislation in the United States. Our representatives in government at all levels are required to take an oath or affirm that they will support the Constitution. They are not required to support their party or their constituency, but the Constitution. Check out this article as it is linked in the Ohio Free Press at www.ohiofreepress.com and my comments there.

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
This article is an absolute disgrace and nothing but a hit piece. Picking out the dozen crazies out of a group of millions is like only showing the Obama supporters who fly Soviet flags and want to end capitalism. The fact that such a hit piece made it to print lets me know as a libertarian that our struggle for liberty is making headway and is scaring the pants off those that love and embrace the current tyranny. Including the Buckeye Firearms Association - which often endorses Democrat candidates - in this tired is especially shameful. There is no other organization that has done so much for gun rights in Ohio (especially for concealed carry and state preemption). Shame on you, Terry Smith. We can disagree politically without resorting to hit pieces. Editor's note: My piece was an opinion column, not an "article." I stand by every word. If you would like to counter it with your own arguments, as you have here, I would urge you to send us a letter to the editor. Those are read by many more people than these comments. Send your letters or op-eds to news@athensnews.com, with your full name and address. Word limit for letters is 400 and op-eds, around 800. -- TS

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
I found your reference to Buckeye Firearms Association as "a hard conservative political group that disguises itself as a gun-rights outfit" to be quite interesting, given our history of endorsing the best candidate on our one issue, no matter what their party. Would a "hard conservative political group" that is just "disguis[ing] itself as a gun-rights outfit" have endorsed or supported four Democrats for U.S. Congress (including Mr. Space,) 27 Democrats for Ohio House, and 2 Democrats for State Senate in 2008? Would such a group have endorsed Democrats Ted Strickland and Marc Dann in 2006? Not a chance. But we did. For a complete history of our endorsements, check our our Voter Guide history: http://www.buckeyefirearms.org/Voter-Guide Editor's note: My point is that you involve yourself in a much broader scope of issues than just gun rights (witness your participation in the right-wing Liberty Council's events), and usually it's coming from a very conservative direction. -- TS

 

Mr. Smith - What you claim was your "point" isn't even close to you said - you said BFA is a "a hard conservative political group that disguises itself as a gun-rights outfit." We are a non-partisan, single issue group no matter where we go to represent it, and there are years of proof in our actions to back that up. Other than our decision to represent gun rights at tea parties (like I said, we represent those rights no matter WHERE we go), would you care to provide proof to your allegation that we are involved "in a much broader scope of issues than just gun rights?" You won't be able to. So instead, why don't you just admit you were mistaken in making those comments?

 

I think you make some good points, though my personal opinion is that the BFA is a hard conservative group, and that's precisely why I would never consider being a member, even though I do own a gun. But yes, I'll concede that your primary focus is gun rights, rather than some broader agenda, and I'm sorry for suggesting otherwise. I've placed a correction in the column. I do wish you folks would consider writing letters to the editor, rather than confining your comments to this relatively little-read forum. TS

 

Thank you for the correction. I'll be happy to send a letter as well.

 

REPLY TO THIS COMMENT
...why not come along to one of these meetings? Reading your estimations, I can safely assume you've never physically been to any of our events. Out of the hundreds of thousands of people (some say as many as 2 million, but even at half that, what a gathering!!) at the Whitehouse on 9/12/10 for an incredibly large rally, NOT ONE complaint, arrest, or bubblegum wrapper left as a negative reminder. Not so for the inauguration...why is that? You missed a lot out of the REAL press release, so let me enlighten those to whom you write: "Tea Party and Liberty Groups Make Candidates Stand and Deliver at District 18 Candidate Nights Mt Vernon, Ohio February 22, 2010. The Ohio Liberty Council, a non-partisan grassroots volunteer organization comprised of leaders from tea party and other liberty-minded groups, has invited all nine candidates running in the Ohio 18th Congressional District primary election to participate in four non-partisan "Candidate Nights" within the district before the primaries in early May. The first candidate night is planned for March 6th at the Mt. Vernon Nazarene University Chapel in Mount Vernon, Ohio. Groups such as Organizing for Freedom and area tea party groups place a high priority on making candidates for elective office answer to the people they wish to represent before primaries and before Election Day. Taxpayers want to be involved, aware and informed. These public events herald a new era of accountability and education. Dan Offineer, Ohio 18 Candidate Nights Coordinator, has been in close contact with each of the candidates. "We are excited to bring out all of the candidates in this very competitive primary race. Many organizations focus on a single party or a single candidate, but the liberty minded groups in District 18 have united in an unprecedented way to invite all of the candidates for the public to judge. These events are not about political parties, but about learning how each of the candidates will represent ‘We the People”." Candidates who have accepted the invitation are: Beau Bromberg, Fred Dailey, Dave Daubenmire, Bob Gibbs, Hombre Liggett, Jeanette Moll, Mark Pitrone, and Helen Wolfe. The incumbent, Representative Zack Space, has not yet formally responded to the certified letter sent to his office in January. Juanita Hockingberry, leader of the Licking County group, Organizing for Freedom, feels that the time is right for this type of interaction with the public. "People are fed up with politics in general. It's become an 'us against them' situation, and it's depressing all facets of our lives: from our attitudes toward our government to our fear to buy a car or a home, or an employer to keep or hire employees because of the instability of the economy. Our goal is to engage and unite the public back into the political process. Our future--and our children’s' -- our grandchildren’s' futures -- depend on it." There are four candidate nights in the 18th district. There is no charge for the events, and the public is encouraged to attend. Following the March 6th candidate night in at Mount Vernon Nazarene University Chapel, other events will follow March through May in the communities of Chillicothe, Zanesville, and New Philadelphia. For more information, to R.S.V.P., and for the opportunity to submit a question that may be personally asked at the events, please visit http://www.ohio18.com. Hockingberry is optimistic about the events. "This is the very best way we can empower voters-- by giving them direct contact with the people whose names they'll see on the ballot. They can ask the questions they want answered. And we are meeting the needs of the four corners of this huge district. This will give them the information they need, enable them to make the best decision for themselves, to make their vote count, and to make a difference in the future of this great country." About the Ohio Liberty Council The Ohio Liberty Council is a coalition of several non-partisan groups in Ohio including Buckeye Firearms Association, Central Ohio 9/12 Project, Cincinnati 9/12 Project, Cincinnati Tea Party, Young Americans for Liberty-OSU, Dayton Tea Party, and the Ohio Freedom Alliance. The council began in June 2009, and was conceived as a way to connect liberty-minded Ohioans. The group communicates on issues, but more importantly seeks to create concerted action among the groups. By working together, the council intends to achieve real results to protect and promote liberty in Ohio. http://www.ohiolibertycouncil.org/" We are only a 'threat' (certainly not physically) to those who have been keeping us 'hostage' (using this term figuratively, now, don't get your shorts all wadded up...), by using US, WE THE PEOPLE to enhance their lavish lifestyles why they carry on their own agenda (why in the world did Zack Space vote for "Cap and Trade" and why don't I have a right to ask and get an answer?), without consideration for the majority of their constituency---who elected them---for whom they are elected to SERVE, not BE SERVED. If there is even a small inkling of doubt about what you are seeing your government doing right before your eyes, come to one of these events and see for yourself just what these "Tea Partiers" are really like, and what we are doing to effect positive change. Civilly, legally and even lovingly for everyone; even those with whom we may, in some realms, disagree. You folks ARE liberty-minded, no less than we are. Really, we're not so different after all...

 

 

 
 
Close
Close
Close